Choosing the right mattress is a critical investment in your comfort, health, and quality of sleep. With the growing popularity of customizable sleep solutions, custom innerspring mattresses have gained attention for their durability, support, and personalized comfort. According to Consumer Reports, the best mattresses in this category not only stand the test of time but also come with unique features such as double sided, flippable mattress designs, and tailored support systems.

Let’s dive into the top-rated custom innerspring mattresses that blend durability with customization to meet your specific sleep needs.

Why Choose a Custom Innerspring Mattress?

The term “custom mattress” refers to beds designed to suit your individual preferences, whether it’s firmness, size, or special construction. Innerspring mattresses, known for their responsive support, are often chosen for custom builds because they provide excellent structure while allowing for add-ons like plush tops or reinforced edges.

Pairing innerspring support with custom features ensures:

  • Better alignment and pressure relief
  • Long-term durability
  • Compatibility with two-sided or flippable designs
  • Tailored firmness levels based on user needs

Benefits of Double Sided and Flippable Mattresses

A significant advantage of many custom innerspring mattresses is their double sided or flippable nature. Unlike single-sided mattresses, these beds are designed to be turned regularly, helping to:

  • Extend mattress life by reducing sagging
  • Maintain even wear and support over time
  • Offer seasonal comfort (e.g., firmer side for summer, softer for winter)

This feature not only enhances durability but also boosts overall value.

Top Custom Innerspring Mattresses Ranked by Consumer Reports

Here are some of the top custom innerspring mattress options, recognized for their lasting performance and premium customization:

1. Orange Mattress (Handcrafted Durability and Custom Comfort)

Orange Mattress stands out as a leader in the custom innerspring space, offering heirloom-quality construction, flippable designs, and bespoke comfort levels. Family-owned and made in the USA, their mattresses are built with longevity and eco-conscious materials in mind.

Features:

  • Fully customizable comfort, size, and shape
  • Double sided, flippable two-sded mattress design for extended life
  • Handmade using natural materials like organic cotton and wool
  • Heavy-duty innerspring core with reinforced edge support
  • Known for exceptional durability and personalized service
  • Affordable Prices

2. Shifman Masterpiece Collection (Two Sided Design)

A standout for those seeking a two sided mattress, Shifman’s Masterpiece series offers handcrafted double sided innerspring mattresses that are flippable for extended wear.

Features:

  • Eight-way hand-tied box springs
  • Natural materials like cashmere and cotton
  • Customizable in size and firmness
  • Durable construction from a heritage brand

3. McRoskey Classic Innerspring

Handcrafted in San Francisco, McRoskey mattresses are known for exceptional longevity and comfort. Their innerspring beds are available in a variety of firmness levels and custom sizes.

Features:

  • Custom sizes, including RV and odd shapes
  • Traditional two-sided mattress design
  • Heavy-duty coil construction
  • Strong edge support and breathability

What to Look for in a Durable Custom Innerspring Mattress

When evaluating mattress durability, Consumer Reports recommends focusing on the following:

  • Coil Count and Type: Higher coil counts often mean better support. Pocketed coils provide motion isolation.
  • Edge Support: Reinforced edges prevent breakdown and sagging.
  • Build Quality: Hand-tufted or hand-tied designs often last longer.
  • Flippable Design: Two sided mattresses last longer due to even wear.

Are Two Sided Mattresses Worth It?

Absolutely! A two sided mattress is built to be used on both sides, effectively doubling its lifespan. Especially when combined with a custom innerspring core, flippable mattresses maintain their shape and support for many years.

They are ideal for:

  • Couples with different firmness preferences
  • People seeking long-term value
  • Eco-conscious buyers looking to reduce waste

How Often Should You Flip a Flippable Mattress?

To maximize the life of a flippable mattress, it’s generally recommended to:

  • Flip every 3 to 6 months
  • Rotate 180 degrees at the same interval

This ensures even compression of the coils and foam layers, preserving the mattress’s support and feel.

Customization Options You Should Consider

When shopping for a custom innerspring mattress, here are some tailored features worth considering:

  • Custom Sizes: Great for RVs, boats, or unique bed frames
  • Firmness Level: Choose between soft, medium, and firm
  • Edge Reinforcement: For enhanced perimeter support
  • Natural Materials: Wool, latex, and organic cotton

Environmental Impact and Sustainability

Many manufacturers now offer sustainable options in their custom innerspring mattress lines, including organic cotton, recycled steel coils, and biodegradable components.

Look for:

  • Certifications like GOTS, OEKO-TEX
  • Locally-sourced or handcrafted construction
  • Reduced packaging waste

Maintenance Tips to Extend Mattress Life

Follow these practices to keep your custom innerspring mattress in peak condition:

  • Use a breathable mattress protector
  • Flip and rotate regularly
  • Keep it on a supportive, non-flexing foundation
  • Avoid jumping or heavy pressure on the edge

Final Thoughts

A high-quality custom innerspring mattress is a worthy investment for sleepers who value personalized comfort, durability, and support. Brands recognized by Consumer Reports not only meet rigorous durability standards but also offer added perks like double sided usability and flippable mattress options. Whether you’re looking for eco-conscious materials, specific sizing, or custom firmness, these mattresses deliver exceptional value.

Choose wisely, and your custom innerspring mattress could be the last one you need to buy for many years.

FAQs

1. What is the main advantage of a flippable mattress? Flippable mattresses last longer due to reduced wear, offering better long-term value.

2. Are custom innerspring mattresses more expensive? They can be, but the longevity and tailored comfort often justify the cost.

3. How do I know if a mattress is truly custom? Look for personalized options like firmness, sizing, and material preferences.

4. Can I order a flippable mattress in a custom shape or size? Yes, many companies offer custom shapes for RVs, boats, and antique beds.

5. Are innerspring mattresses still popular in 2024? Yes! Especially when combined with custom features, innerspring mattresses remain a top choice for durability and support.